1967,
Cubberly High School, Palo Alto California.
World
HistoryTeacher Ron Jones is asked about the
Holocaust by a student, and "Could it happen
here?" Jones came up with an unusual answer. Ron
decided to have a two week experiment in
dictatorship. His idea was to explain fascism to
his class through a game, nothing more. He never
intended what resulted, where his class would be
turned into a Fascist environment. Where
students gave up their freedom for the prospect
of being superior to their neighbors.
Monday morning he straightened the classroom,
dimmed the lights and played Wagnerian music.
The word "discipline" was written on the
blackboard. He then had the students sit up
straight in their chairs with hands placed flat
across the small of their backs. In this
setting, he devoted the remainder of the class
to the topic of discipline.
By the second day, Jones developed a special
greeting, a wave. It became known as the Third
Wave, and if students saw each other outside
class, they were to use it. In his lectures,
Jones went from "discipline," to "strength
through community," and then to "strength
through action."
By midweek, his "experiment" expanded to sixty
students, and by the week's end, more than two
hundred were participating. Other teachers and
the school's principal stood by and watched.
The first sign of concern came when some
students had taken it upon themselves to report
others who did not conform. After just four days,
things got out of hand. Jones feared for the
safety of a few students who refused to
participate. To his dismay and alarm, the
experiment was so blindly embraced by the
students, that he cut the project short. "Initially
I just wanted to show my students how powerful
the pressure to belong can be, but the exercise
got out of control. A momentum began to build
that I couldn't slow, or even deter. I became
frightened by the day-to-day happenings in class,
and was forced to call it off," recalls Jones.
Overnight, Jones became the subject of national
controversy, sparking discussion on the
appropriateness of exposing young adults to
life's realities. To some, he was an innovative
hero and teacher; to others he was a Communist.
Many people were shocked and embarrassed that
the same mentality which led to the Holocaust
could develop so quickly, in 1967, in a pristine
all-American setting, and an academic town no
less, home to the well-known Stanford University.
Jones wrote of his "experiment" in a short
story, titled "Take As Directed", which was
published in an alternative publication, The
Whole Earth Review. Norman Lear, an American
film maker, made a television adaptation which
won Peabody and Emmy awards; however, in the
process, he dramatically changed Jones' original
true story. Later, a novel was published based
on the teleplay, becoming a best seller in
Europe. To date, over 1.5 million copies have
been sold, and the story is required reading in
German schools. The irony of the teleplay, the
novel, and some of the plays produced since the
original publication of Jones' story, is that
they fail to tell what really happened in the
classroom.